I set up a specific email address as a target that receives email notifications when a ticket is updated. When the recipient of that target replies to the email notification, a new ticket is created, rather than having their reply threaded to the original ticket. I expect their reply to be added as an entry to the same ticket that the notification was sent from.
Why do replies to email-target notifications create a new ticket? How can I ensure customer email replies are added to the first ticket instead of creating a new ticket?
The target notification system is not designed to thread to an existing ticket and it is expected behavior that a new ticket is created.
To allow this end user's email replies to thread to the original ticket, stop using targets as your notification method. Instead, CC the end user to your ticket so that they receive a CC notification. If they reply to that notification, the reply is added to the ticket as a public comment.
For more information on how you can customize your CC notification settings, see the article: Configuring CC and follower permissions.
Alternatively, Ontec authored a paid app in the Marketplace that allows you to forward entire ticket conversations to any external email. When the recipient replies to the forwarded email, their comment threads to the original ticket as a private comment.